In football, Alabama and Florida supposedly got all the calls this past fall.
In basketball, it’s Kentucky that’s been “taken care of.”
At least that’s the way many SEC fans saw things this year at least.
I don’t know who thought Kentucky was getting all the calls when Billy Gillispie was missing the NCAA tournament last year.
And I don’t remember anyone talking about Bama getting help from officials during Nick Saban’s first 7-6 season in Tuscaloosa.
But, hey, the perception is that good teams really aren’t that good… they’re just being aided by the refs. Or so a lot of people seem to think.
So I’ve gone back through every Southeastern Conference basketball game this season (that’s 96 regular season games) and tallied up all of the fouls called in each game. Below you’ll see which teams were whistled for the most fouls, which teams saw their opponents most often called for fouls, and which teams got the biggest boost in foul differential per game.
Keep in mind, this is purely a numbers exercise. There’s no way to know how numbers are skewed by the fact that good teams usually lead and therefore their opponents are forced to foul more at the ends of games.
In other words, are fouls called because a team is good or is a team good because fouls are called? Depending on your belief in conspiracy theories, that can go either way.
Also, it would stand to reason that more talented teams would force their opponents to foul more in an attempt to even the playing field. In other words, not everyone has a guard as fast as John Wall, so it would figure that Wall might draw more slaps on the arms as he blows down the lane.
In addition, more physical teams — like Vanderbilt — probably get a foul advantage because other teams have to use multiple players to bang around inside with them.
Personally, I’m not a believer in conspiracy theories. I believe home teams get more calls because officials get caught up in crowd noise just as players do (and we’ll show you those numbers, too). I believe more talented teams get “benefit of the doubt” calls. And I believe teams that have a reputation for being physical get more calls in their favor as well.
But I don’t believe officials take care of certain teams in order to protect their rankings, seedings, etc. You might, but I don’t.
All that said, here are the numbers:
MOST FOULS CALLED AGAINST OPPONENT PER GAME
| School |
Fouls Against Opp. Per Game |
SEC Record |
| Vanderbilt |
22.87 |
12-4 |
| Kentucky |
20.75 |
14-2 |
| Arkansas |
19.56 |
7-9 |
| Tennessee |
17.81 |
11-5 |
| Auburn |
17.62 |
6-10 |
| Florida |
17.00 |
9-7 |
| Mississippi State |
17.00 |
9-7 |
| Ole Miss |
16.50 |
9-7 |
| Georgia |
16.06 |
5-11 |
| Alabama |
15.87 |
6-10 |
| LSU |
15.68 |
2-14 |
| South Carolina |
15.00 |
6-10 |
It seems that Auburn and Arkansas tend to spoil the conspiracy theory on this one.
FEWEST FOULS CALLED AGAINST PER GAME
| School |
Fouls Called Against Per Game |
SEC Record |
| Florida |
14.06 |
9-7 |
| Mississippi State |
15.06 |
9-7 |
| Georgia |
16.37 |
5-11 |
| LSU |
17.00 |
2-14 |
| Kentucky |
17.12 |
14-2 |
| South Carolina |
18.00 |
6-10 |
| Alabama |
18.18 |
6-10 |
| Arkansas |
18.50 |
7-9 |
| Tennessee |
18.87 |
11-5 |
| Ole Miss |
18.93 |
9-7 |
| Auburn |
19.75 |
6-10 |
| Vanderbilt |
19.87 |
12-4 |
Again, I’m not seeing any evidence of conspiracies here. Vanderbilt saw it’s opponents whistled for more fouls than any other school. Yet the Commodores also led the league in the number of fouls that were called against them. That seems to suggest that style of play is a pretty big factor.
As for Kentucky, the Wildcats were actually whistled for more fouls than Florida, Mississippi State, Georgia and LSU. That would be 2-14 LSU, by the way.
FOUL DIFFERENTIAL PER GAME
| School |
Differential in Fouls Called Per Game |
SEC Record |
| Kentucky |
3.63 |
14-2 |
| Vanderbilt |
3.00 |
12-4 |
| Florida |
2.94 |
9-7 |
| Mississippi State |
1.94 |
9-7 |
| Arkansas |
1.06 |
7-9 |
| Georgia |
-0.31 |
5-11 |
| Tennessee |
-1.06 |
11-5 |
| LSU |
-1.32 |
2-14 |
| Auburn |
-2.13 |
6-10 |
| Alabama |
-2.31 |
6-10 |
| Ole Miss |
-2.43 |
9-7 |
| South Carolina |
-3.00 |
6-10 |
Finally. Something for the folks in the tin foil hats.
No school sees a bigger difference between their own number of fouls and their opponents’ fouls than Kentucky. Of course, the SEC refs are having to be awfully sneaky about this if it’s planned out… because UK doesn’t lead either of the two individual categories (above) that are used to determine this number.
But what about homecourt advantage? Is it real?
Oh, yes. There’s a reason 76% of BCS league games have been won by the home team in recent years. A loud crowd influences players AND officials.
All 12 teams in the SEC this past year saw more fouls called against their opponents at home than on the road. All 12.
And all 12 SEC teams saw fewer fouls called on themselves when playing at home, too. Again, all 12.
But of all the official-affecting home gyms in the SEC, here are the ones that provide the best advantage for their occupants:
FOUL DIFFERENTIAL AT HOME
| School |
Differential in Fouls Called Per Game |
Home Record |
| Florida |
6.87 |
6-2 |
| Kentucky |
5.78 |
8-0 |
| Vanderbilt |
5.00 |
6-2 |
| Arkansas |
4.00 |
5-3 |
| Georgia |
3.12 |
5-3 |
| Mississippi State |
2.88 |
6-2 |
| Auburn |
1.88 |
5-3 |
| Tennessee |
0.88 |
7-1 |
| LSU |
0.87 |
2-6 |
| Alabama |
0.37 |
4-4 |
| Ole Miss |
-0.38 |
4-4 |
| South Carolina |
-1.87 |
4-4 |
As you can see, only two SEC teams (Ole Miss and South Carolina) averaged more fouls called against them than their opponents at home. Every other team had a positive foul differential in their own gym.
Of all the gyms in the SEC in 2010, the O’Connell Center in Gainesville was the most inhospitable to visitors looking to get a call or two.
Join the forum discussion on this post - (1) Posts